| Date | Location | Result | |
| 5/15/2021 | Lancaster, Pa. | Franklin&Marshall 16, John Carroll 9 | |
| 5/8/2021 | Berea, Ohio | John Carroll 12, Baldwin Wallace 6 | |
| 5/6/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 10, Otterbein 3 | |
| 5/1/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 14, Otterbein 2 | |
| 4/24/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 25, Muskingum 3 | |
| 4/21/2021 | Alliance, Ohio | John Carroll 21, Mount Union 3 | |
| 4/17/2021 | Marietta, Ohio | John Carroll 25, Marietta 4 | |
| 4/10/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 32, Wilmington 4 | |
| 4/7/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 10, Baldwin Wallace 6 | |
| 4/3/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 29, Heidelberg 0 | |
| 3/27/2021 | Ada, Ohio | John Carroll 17, Ohio Northern 6 | |
| 3/20/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 17, Mount Union 5 | |
| 3/17/2021 | University Hts, Ohio | John Carroll 26, Marietta 2 | |
| 3/13/2021 | Columbus, Ohio | John Carroll 27, Capital 9 | |
| 3/6/2021 | Berea, Ohio | Baldwin Wallace 10, John Carroll 9 | |
| 2/27/2021 | Tiffin, Ohio | John Carroll 32, Heidelberg 1 |